In partnership with Auto Trader
Used test: Hyundai Kona Electric vs Vauxhall Mokka-e vs Volkswagen ID 3 costs
With savings of around £10,000 off new, each of these two-year-old electric cars could be considered incredibly tempting buys. Which is best deserving of esteem, though? We find out...
Buying and owning
Costs, equipment, reliability, safety
At three years old, the Hyundai Kona Electric and Vauxhall Mokka-e come in at around £21,000 each, although the Mokka lost around £2500 more of its value to get there. The Volkswagen ID 3 lost the least amount of its value as it descended to around £24,000.
The Kona Electric should also be the cheapest to insure; its in the lowest insurance group of our trio – 21. It should cost around £618 to insure, while the Mokka-e (group 22) around £640 and the ID 3 (group 27) around £741.
As of writing, the Kona Electric will have around two years left on the five-year/100,000-mile warranty it received from new. The Mokka will be on its final year of its three-year/60,000-mile manufacturer warranty, while its battery will continue to be covered by a eight-year/100,000-mile policy. It's the same case with the ID 3.
For a single service of the Kona Electric, we were quoted just £63 by Hyundai. Vauxhall offered three services as part of its plan on the Mokka-e, but at a cost of £600. For one service of the ID 3, Volkswagen quoted £338, although it was the only service plan to include an MOT at no additional cost.
Although the ID 3 has the stingiest standard equipment tally (including steel wheels with plastic trims), you still get climate control, heated front seats, a heated steering wheel and adaptive cruise control. Both the Kona and Mokka add keyless entry and alloy wheels.
The Mokka and ID.3 are able to charge at a rate of up to 100kW, while the Kona is slower with a 50kW maximum. Balance that with the size of their batteries and the Mokka takes a little less than half an hour to get from 10-80% via a suitable CCS rapid charger, with the ID 3 taking just over 30 minutes and the Kona around 45 minutes. If you’re plugging into a typical 7kW home wallbox, the Kona takes about six and a half hours to go from 0-100%, the Mokka seven and a half hours and the ID 3 a bit over nine hours.
In our latest What Car? Reliability Survey, the Kona Electric placed 11th out of 14 cars in the electric car class, while the ID 3 ranked eighth. The Mokka-e didn't feature. As brands, Hyundai managed an impressive fifth place finish out of 32 manufacturers; Vauxhall came 23rd and Volkswagen 22nd.
During safety testing conducted by Euro NCAP, the ID 3 received the maximum five stars. The Kona Electric and Mokka-e weren't specifically tested, but the standard Kona got five stars and the standard Mokka four stars.
